1. Blog
  2. Buying guides

Buying guides

Best recruitment software: which type does your hiring team need?

Ed Godshaw, Co-founder and CTO, Alfa AI ·

Three colleagues at a wooden table by an office window compare printed charts, one pointing at a sheet

The best recruitment software depends on the job you need done: an employer's system of record, an agency's system of record, an AI recruiter alongside an ATS, sourcing, or interviewing. There is no single best product across those jobs.

Alfa AI publishes this guide. Alfa AI is an AI recruiter, not an ATS, and is one of nine products described here. Products are grouped by job, not ranked.

How we chose and checked these recruitment software products

We started from the products named in AI assistant answers to this question, in review-site categories for recruiting software and in ranking roundups, all read on November 20, 2026. We kept a product only when we could verify at least six facts about it on the vendor's own pages that day. We then describe one or two products per job. Which of the products that passed we describe was our editorial decision, not a score, so this list is not exhaustive: other products pass the same test, and a product's absence says nothing about it.

The roundups we read had no category for an AI recruiter working on top of an ATS. We added that category with our own product and two vendors describing their products as an AI recruiting agent or AI recruiter. Choosing Pin and Humanly as those two was also our editorial decision.

Product statements come from vendors' own pages, checked on November 20, 2026. We excluded review-site scores, unpublished prices, profile-database sizes and security certifications because we could not compare them like for like. Unpublished prices appear as “not stated by the vendor” for every product, including Alfa AI. Ask every vendor, including Alfa AI, for current audit reports. Products and prices change, so confirm details on the vendor's page.

We checked data location on the vendor's own pages for four products only: Alfa AI, Workable, Manatal and Juicebox. We did not check it for Bullhorn, Pin, Humanly, HireVue or Paradox, so ask every vendor, including Alfa AI, where candidate data is stored and where it is processed.

If a statement about your product is wrong or out of date, corrections can be requested through the contact details on welovealfa.com.

Recruitment software by job

ProductJob it doesWho it suits (in the vendor's words)Replaces or works with your ATSHow it chargesPublished price, checked November 20, 2026
WorkableATS and HRCompanies of all sizes and in any industrySystem of recordMonthly by company size; Agent uses creditsRecruiting only, 1 to 20 employees, annual billing: Standard from $299 a month; Premier from $599 a month; Enterprise from $719 a month
BullhornAgency ATS and CRMStaffing agencies of any sizeSystem of recordSmall-agency plans: per user per month, with Pro and Max quoted; larger-agency plans: get a quoteSmall-agency plans, UK: Starter £80; Core £120 per user per month. Small-agency plans, US: Starter $99; Core $165 per user per month. Pro, Max and the larger-agency plans: not stated by the vendor
ManatalATS and client CRMHR teams, recruitment agencies and headhuntersSystem of recordPer user per month; prices shown are for annual billingProfessional $15; Enterprise $35; Enterprise Plus $55; Custom: not stated by the vendor
PinOutbound sourcing and outreachAgencies, founders and enterprise talent teamsWorks alongside your ATSPer user per month, with contact lookup creditsFree $0; Solo $100, annual only; Professional $135 annually or $179 monthly; Enterprise: not stated by the vendor
HumanlyScreening, scheduling and AI interviewsHourly, frontline and high-volume hiring teamsWorks with an ATS or offers its ownStream: platform-based, pay per qualified candidate or pay per hirenot stated by the vendor
Alfa AIAdvertising, sourcing, applicant screening and first-round AI InterviewsEmployers and staffing firms in the UK and USWorks alongside your ATS, including Workable and BullhornSubscription with monthly sourcing credits; enterprise quotednot stated by the vendor
JuiceboxCandidate sourcingRecruiters searching for hard-to-find talentWorks with your ATS; connections on BusinessPer seat per month, plus contact creditsFree $0; Starter $119 monthly or $99 yearly; Growth $199 monthly or $179 yearly; Business: not stated by the vendor
HireVueVideo interviews, AI interviewer and assessmentsMid-market to enterprise; RPO and staffing firmsWorks with your ATSNo published price; the pricing page directs buyers to a demo requestnot stated by the vendor
ParadoxText screening and schedulingFrontline high-volume hourly and high-skilled professional rolesConversational ATS typically replaces it; Candidate Experience Agent plugs into itCustom pricing; charging unit not stated by the vendornot stated by the vendor

For Pin and Juicebox, annual/yearly figures are monthly rates with annual billing, not the total annual cost.

System of record for employers: an ATS

Workable

Workable combines an ATS covering requisitions through offers with HR functions after hire. Consider it when you want recruiting and employee administration on the same platform. Standard starts from $299 a month for the 1 to 20 employee band, recruiting only, with annual billing. Its Agent uses AI credits, and the free trial excludes the Agent. Test the agent separately from your assessment of the ATS.

Workable's sub-processor list places its Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud Platform and MongoDB hosting in the US East region.

Manatal

Manatal's Professional plan costs $15 per user per month billed annually, with up to 15 jobs and up to 10,000 candidates. It is worth considering for HR or agency teams seeking an ATS with a client CRM included in every plan. Check the plan limits against your workload. Workflow automations require Enterprise or Enterprise Plus; API access requires Enterprise Plus. Monthly plans cost $19, $39 and $59 per user per month. Manatal states that all customer data is stored in the USA.

System of record for agencies: ATS and CRM

Bullhorn

Bullhorn is built for staffing agencies, managing candidates, jobs, shifts and clients together. Of the pricing pages we checked on November 20, 2026, Bullhorn's UK page was the only one we found showing prices in pounds: Starter £80 and Core £120 per user per month, under the heading “Bullhorn plans and pricing for small agencies”. Its plans for larger agencies, Front Office Growth and Front Office Enterprise, show “Get a quote” and no price. Bullhorn says it offers small-agency plans for teams of 1 to 10.

Bullhorn's pricing page lists AI capabilities from the Pro plan, which is quoted; the Starter and Core lists do not name them. The Max plan adds agentic screening, multi-step AI outreach and interview scheduling. Manatal also includes a client CRM in every plan. We did not check where Bullhorn stores data.

AI recruiters that work on top of your ATS

These tools perform recruiter tasks such as sourcing, screening, first interviews and scheduling, then hand candidates to the system of record. Set the workflow so people approve the work and make hiring decisions.

Alfa AI is listed last in this group because it is our own product; the order is not a ranking.

Pin

For outbound search and outreach with self-serve pricing, consider Pin, which finds people, handles replies and books calls. Solo costs $100 per user per month, billed annually only.

Outreach emails are sent from the recruiter's own connected Gmail or Outlook account. LinkedIn steps appear as tasks for the user, and text messages are drafted for the user to send.

ATS integration is an add-on on Solo and Professional, included on Enterprise and not included on Free. The add-on price is not stated by the vendor. We did not check where Pin stores data.

Humanly

Humanly suits high-volume hourly and frontline hiring, combining engagement, screening, scheduling and AI interviews. It writes screening results into an existing ATS or provides its own.

Its AI Recruiter uses chat, SMS and email with recruiter-defined questions and knockout criteria. AI interviews run by chat, voice or video. Recruiters and hiring managers always make the final hiring decision.

It publishes no price list; Stream names platform-based, pay per qualified candidate and pay per hire pricing. It is available in select markets, which it does not name; establish availability before a pilot. We did not check where Humanly stores data.

Alfa AI

Alfa AI combines advertising, outbound sourcing, screening against job rules and first-round AI Interviews, sending candidates to chosen ATS stages. It fits teams wanting these tasks together alongside their ATS; people make hiring decisions.

Prices are unpublished. Accounts are set up after a demo, with no self-serve trial. Candidate records, resumes, recordings and transcripts are stored in the UK (London). Some processing runs outside the UK and the EU, mainly in the US. UK-only or EU-only processing is unavailable.

Sourcing and interviewing tools

Juicebox

For hard-to-find talent, Juicebox lets recruiters search in natural language and builds a ranked candidate pool. Its trust center says its AI “is designed to be used in the pre-application phase only” and that hosting is in the United States.

Seat subscriptions include contact credits; Starter includes 500 monthly contact credits; Growth includes 1,500 per seat. Agents cost an additional $199 per agent per month. Only email outreach steps send automatically; others create user tasks. ATS connections require Business. Use the candidate sourcing guide to define a search before comparing results.

HireVue

HireVue offers on-demand (one-way) and live video interviews, two-way AI interviews with questions and probing follow-up questions, and game-based and coding assessments. It serves mid-market to enterprise and RPO and staffing firms.

It states it does not use facial analysis to evaluate candidates in assessments. With ATS integrations, each stage change is automatically reflected in the customer's ATS. Candidates can opt out of AI interviews; recruiters make the final call.

It publishes no prices. We did not check where HireVue stores data. Prepare a consistent interview brief using the AI interviewer setup guide.

Paradox

Paradox screens role requirements through text conversations and can schedule qualified candidates automatically. It serves frontline high-volume hourly and high-skilled professional roles. Applicants can start applications and screening through SMS, WhatsApp or Facebook Messenger with Text-to-Apply.

Its Conversational ATS typically replaces an ATS; its Candidate Experience Agent plugs into an existing one. Recruiters decide what the Agent can say and do and when it hands off to a human. Specify which product you are buying. Pricing is customized and no amount is published. We did not check where Paradox stores data.

When an ATS alone is the better fit

If your problem is tracking applicants, approvals and offers, and your team can read every application, buy the ATS and stop there.

Add an AI recruiter, sourcing tool or interviewing tool only when a specific step is the bottleneck. An AI recruiter does not replace the system of record.

How recruitment software is priced

Compare charging units before comparing totals. Workable charges by company size and month, with credits for Agent actions. Bullhorn's small-agency plans, Manatal and Pin charge per user; Bullhorn's plans for larger agencies show no price. Juicebox charges per seat, with contact credits. Alfa AI combines a subscription with sourcing credits.

HireVue and Humanly publish no price, and neither does Alfa AI. Paradox says it creates custom pricing tailored to your hiring needs. Humanly's Stream offering names three pricing options without amounts: platform-based, pay per qualified candidate and pay per hire.

Ask about add-ons, expiring credits, annual-only plans and trial exclusions. For example, each Workable ATS plan comes with 3,000 complimentary AI credits; credits expire one year after purchase, and the free trial excludes the Agent. Pin's Solo plan is billed annually only. Manatal's free trial excludes free and premium job board posting. Alfa AI has no self-serve trial.

How to choose recruitment software

  1. Write down the job and bottleneck. Specify the task you need completed and where candidates currently wait.
  2. Choose the system of record first. Decide where applications, approvals and offers belong.
  3. Check the ATS integration. Test stage mapping, duplicate handling and write-back with the ATS integration guide.
  4. Price the whole year. Include users, company size, add-ons, credits and implementation in a written quote.
  5. Check storage and processing. Ask where records live and where each service processes them. This applies to every product in the guide, including Alfa AI, which processes some data in the US.
  6. Check who decides. Require a demonstration of human review, overrides and candidate alternatives.
  7. Pilot on a live role. Define acceptance criteria first, then inspect candidate handoffs and the evidence behind recommendations.

Recruitment software buying checklist

Is this our system of record, or does it work with one?
Which ATS stages and fields can it write to?
What does a year cost for our headcount, including add-ons and credits?
Is the price published, and what changes at renewal?
Do credits expire, and are any plans annual-only?
Does the trial include the AI features we need?
Where is candidate data stored and processed?
Which steps run without a person, and who makes hiring decisions?
Can candidates opt out or request human review of an automated step?
Can we see a bias audit and current security audit reports?
What must the pilot demonstrate before we commit?
What happens to our data if we leave?

UK, US and EU rules to check before you buy AI hiring software

This is not legal advice. Check the proposed workflow against the applicable rules:

Keep a person in the decision and ask for the audit. Use the UK AI recruitment checklist to prepare questions about your intended workflow.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best recruiting software for a small business?
The best recruiting software for a small business depends on the job. For a system of record, compare Workable Standard, from $299 a month for the 1 to 20 employee band (recruiting only, annual billing), with Manatal Professional at $15 per user per month billed annually, with up to 15 jobs and up to 10,000 candidates. The two charge in different units, by company size and by user, so price your own headcount before comparing them.
What is the best software for recruitment agencies?
For recruitment agencies, consider Bullhorn, which is built for staffing agencies, and Manatal, which includes a client CRM in every plan. Bullhorn's UK pricing page lists its small-agency plans: Starter at £80 and Core at £120 per user per month, with Pro and Max quoted. Its plans for larger agencies show no price. Compare the client workflow and the features included in the quoted plan.
Do I still need an ATS if I use an AI recruiter?
Yes, an AI recruiter hands candidates to the system of record and does not replace it. Pin explicitly states that it works alongside an ATS, not as a replacement, and Alfa AI is not an ATS. Establish where the hiring record belongs before choosing software to perform recruiting tasks around it.
How much does recruitment software cost?
Recruitment software vendors charge in different units: Manatal starts at $15 per user per month billed annually, Bullhorn Starter, a small-agency plan, costs £80 per user per month, and Workable Standard starts from $299 a month for 1 to 20 employees, recruiting only, annual billing. HireVue, Paradox, Humanly and Alfa AI publish no price.
What is the best recruitment automation software?
The best recruitment automation software depends on which step needs automation. Use the guide's job groups to separate sourcing and outreach from screening, interviewing and scheduling. Specify the input, the action and the person responsible for reviewing the result. Compare products against that task, including the handoff to your system of record, without assuming a single winner.
What should I check before using AI recruitment software in the UK?
Before using AI recruitment software in the UK, check Equality Act 2010 section 39, the ICO guidance on solely automated decisions and the government's Responsible AI in Recruitment guidance. Keep a person in the decision and ask for evidence that the proposed workflow supports your obligations. The ICO guidance is draft guidance for consultation. This is not legal advice.
Your AI recruiter

Alfa sources, screens and shortlists candidates, so your team only spends time on the people worth meeting.