1. Blog
  2. Interviewing

Interviewing

One-way video interview: how to set up and score a fair first round

Alfie Whattam, Co-founder and CEO, Alfa AI ·

A hiring manager in headphones watching a recorded candidate answer on a laptop, with a printed scoring sheet and pen on the desk

What is a one-way video interview?

A one-way video interview is a first-round interview in which candidates record answers to set questions at a time that suits them, nobody responds, and the hiring team watches the recordings later. It is also called an asynchronous video interview or pre-recorded video interview.

How a one-way video interview works

  1. Invite only applicants who pass screening against the job's requirements.
  2. Write the prompts and scoring criteria together.
  3. Choose preparation time, answer limits, retakes, a deadline and alternatives.
  4. Send an invitation explaining the format, review process and support contact.
  5. Candidates record their answers before the deadline.
  6. Reviewers score the recordings, agree who moves forward and communicate next steps.

When a one-way video interview fits

Recorded interviews are most often used when there are many applicants for similar roles. Include review capacity in your high-volume hiring plan.

SituationGood fit?Why
Similar roles with shared screening criteriaYesFixed prompts support comparison against the same requirements.
Candidates need flexibility about when they respondYes, with alternativesThey can choose when to record.
The role needs discussion, clarification or persuasionPrefer a live screenBoth sides need to ask follow-up questions.
You need to observe someone doing the workUse a work sampleA recorded explanation may not demonstrate the skill.

One-way, AI and live interviews compared

A one-way interview has fixed prompts with nobody responding. An AI interview is a conversation that can follow up and skip covered ground. A live phone screen needs a recruiter's time for every candidate.

FormatWho responds to the candidateWhen the candidate takes itWhat the reviewer gets
One-way video interviewNobodyBefore the deadlineRecorded answers
Conversational AI interviewAI interviewerOn demand where supportedConversation record and assessment, depending on setup
Live phone screenRecruiterAt an agreed timeInterview notes

How to write one-way video interview questions

  • Ask one question per prompt, with supporting cues about the evidence needed.
  • Avoid gimmicks such as describing yourself in three words.
  • Show prompts in writing as well as on video.
  • Say how many prompts there are before candidates start.

Use the interview question writer to draft role-specific prompts, then check each against the job requirements. These settings are a starting point to adjust, not a standard.

Role: ___
Prompt 1 (warm-up, about the role): Why does this role appeal to you, and what do you know about what it involves?
Prompt 2 (past behaviour): Tell us about a time you ___. What did you do, and what happened?
Prompt 3 (situation): Imagine ___. What would you do first, and why?
Prompt 4 (practical, only if the role needs it): ___
Prompt 5 (questions and adjustments): Is there anything you would like to ask us, or anything we should know to make the next stage work for you?
Preparation time per prompt: 1 minute
Answer limit per prompt: 2 minutes
Retakes: 1 per prompt
Deadline: 5 days from the invitation
Written or audio alternative: offered to anyone who asks

Worked example for a customer service adviser

For a contact center role, fill the assessment prompts as follows:

  • Prompt 2 “Tell us about a time you calmed down a customer who was upset. What did you do, and what happened?” This tests de-escalation through the candidate's actions.
  • Prompt 3 “Imagine a customer calls about a late refund and the system shows no record of their order. What would you do first, and why?” This tests problem-solving without guessing.
  • Prompt 4 “Read this short customer email aloud and explain in a sentence or two how you would reply” (shown on screen). This tests an accurate customer response; retain it only if spoken explanation matters to the role.

Display this fictional email with the practical prompt:

Hello, the item in my order arrived damaged. Can you help me understand what I should do next?

Each prompt tests a specific job requirement and can draw on the candidate's own experience. Accept examples from work, study or volunteering. Supply necessary context; none should require insider knowledge of your systems or policies.

Settings that decide whether candidates finish

SettingWhat to chooseWhy
Number of promptsThree to fiveKeep the task focused on screening.
Preparation timeEnough to read and think; show the prompt before the timer startsSeparate understanding from answering.
Answer limitShort, with a visible timerMake expectations clear.
RetakesAllow at least oneA first camera attempt can fail for reasons unrelated to the job.
DeadlineSeveral days, including a weekendGive candidates flexibility.
DeviceWorks on a phone browser without installing an appAvoid requiring another device or download.
Alternative formatAudio or written answers for anyone who asks, without needing a reasonMake access straightforward.
Named contactA real person's email for problemsProvide a route to help.

Candidate invitation template

Replace every placeholder and confirm the stated settings and retention period match your process. For AI analysis, add the applicable notice and consent request before asking for the video, as covered below.

Subject: Your first-round interview for ___ at ___

Hi ___,

Thanks for applying for ___. The next step is a short recorded interview you can do at any time before ___.

What to expect:
- ___ questions, shown in writing and on video
- ___ to prepare and up to ___ to answer each one
- One retake per question
- Works on a phone or computer browser; no download needed

Who watches it: ___ from our hiring team will watch your answers and decide the next step. Your recording is used only for this application and kept for ___.

If you need adjustments, such as more time, captions or answering in writing or by audio instead, reply to this email and we will arrange it. You do not need to give a reason.

Start here: ___

If anything goes wrong, contact ___ at ___.

___

How to score recorded answers

Recordings are comparable only when reviewers use the same criteria and scale. Build an interview scorecard before sending invitations. Agree the progression rule, including essential criteria and how to handle missing evidence, before reviewers see candidates.

Use 1 for no relevant evidence, 2 for partial evidence, 3 for clear evidence and 4 for clear evidence with sound reasoning. Arrange another response after a technical failure. Keep the warm-up and candidate questions unscored.

PromptWhat a strong answer showsWhat a weak answer showsScore (1 to 4)
Prompt 2, upset customerListens, explains personal actions and describes the outcomeBlames the customer or gives no actions___
Prompt 3, missing refundChecks details, investigates and explains next steps without unsupported promisesGuesses or promises an unverified refund___
Prompt 4, customer emailAddresses the request accurately and offers a relevant next stepMisses the request or invents commitments___

Illustrative refund answer: “I'd confirm the customer's order details, check the available records and explain what I need to investigate before promising a refund.” Score 3: clear evidence of verification and expectation-setting; the strongest answer would also explain why those steps come first.

  • Score each prompt before moving to the next candidate's answer to that prompt.
  • Score the content, not the candidate's background, accent, camera, room or confidence on camera.
  • Write one line of evidence for every score.
  • Have a second reviewer score a sample of recordings and compare results.
  • Decide who moves on from scores and evidence, not a gut reaction to the video.

Adjustments and alternatives

Acas says UK employers must ask interview candidates whether they need reasonable adjustments. Include recorded interviews in that request.

Equality Act section 20 requires reasonable steps to avoid substantial disadvantage for disabled people from practices or physical features, and to provide auxiliary aids where needed.

Offer:

  • Extra preparation or answer time.
  • Captions or written prompts.
  • Audio-only or written answers.
  • A live call instead.
  • More time before the deadline.

Keep the job criteria consistent across formats. Leave adjustment requests unscored, and have the named contact answer candidates' questions.

Rules to check before sending invitations

This is not legal advice. Check the current law where the role is based.

UK recording and automated decisions

Acas says employers must get permission before recording and handle recordings and notes securely, confidentially and under data protection rules.

Under UK GDPR Articles 22A to 22D, a decision is solely automated when there is no meaningful human involvement; a significant decision has legal or similarly significant effects. For significant, solely automated decisions, Article 22C requires safeguards: information about the decision, opportunities to make representations, human intervention and the ability to contest it.

I'd have a person watch recordings and decide, with authority to change an AI recommendation. Check the wider process using the UK AI recruitment guide.

Illinois AI video interviews

For positions based in Illinois, the Artificial Intelligence Video Interview Act requires notice that AI may analyze the video and assess fitness, an explanation of how it works and the general types of characteristics evaluated, and consent before requesting the video. Do not use AI to evaluate applicants who have not consented.

Sharing is limited to people whose expertise or technology is necessary to evaluate fitness for the role.

Delete videos and all electronic backups within 30 days of receiving an applicant's request, and instruct recipients to delete them too.

If AI analysis alone decides who gets an in-person interview, collect race and ethnicity data for applicants offered and not offered that interview, and those hired; report annually to the Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity by December 31.

New York City automated hiring tools

For covered automated employment decision tools, New York City's Local Law 144 requires a bias audit within a year of use, publicly available audit information and candidate notice 10 business days before use. Check whether your process falls within its scope before sending invitations.

Measure whether it works

Review these measures monthly, including candidates using alternative formats.

MeasureHow to calculate itWhat a change tells you
Invitations completedCompleted interviews divided by invitations sentPossible friction in the invitation or task
Time from invitation to completionCompletion timestamp minus invitation timestampWhether timing needs investigation
Adjustment requestsRequests divided by invitations sent, grouped by request typeWhich access needs to plan for
Reviewer agreement on the second-review sampleMatching ratings divided by ratings comparedWhether scoring anchors need clarification
Candidates moved on per recording reviewedCandidates advanced divided by recordings reviewedWhether screening and prompts align
Selection rate by group at this stageCandidates advanced divided by candidates assessed, within each groupDifferences needing investigation

If completion falls, check invitation delivery, the mobile experience and support requests. If reviewers disagree, compare their evidence and clarify the rating descriptions before reviewing more candidates.

How Alfa handles the first-round interview

Alfa's AI Interview is a conversation with Lisa, an AI interviewer, rather than a one-way recording. Lisa uses the candidate's resume and job details for context and can skip questions already covered. Candidates join through their browser when it suits them, using video or audio according to the employer's settings.

Before joining, candidates are told the interview is recorded, transcribed and assessed by AI, and that a person on the hiring team will review it. A person reviews every recording and decides the next step. The candidate profile shows the recording and transcript beside a scorecard containing the AI score and supporting evidence.

Frequently asked questions

What is a one-way video interview?
A one-way video interview is a first-round interview in which the candidate records answers to set questions at a time that suits them, with nobody on the other side responding, and the hiring team watches the recordings later. For agencies, specify whether your team, the client or both will review the answers before you send the invitation.
How do one-way video interviews work?
The employer writes the prompts and settings, sends each candidate a link, the candidate records an answer to each prompt before the deadline, and reviewers score the recordings against the same rubric. Give the process an owner who can resolve incomplete submissions and tell candidates what happens next, so recordings do not sit in an unattended queue.
Are one-way video interviews reviewed by a person?
One-way video interviews should be reviewed by a person on the hiring team who watches the recordings and makes the decision; when software alone makes a significant decision, UK law requires safeguards including human intervention. A human reviewer needs the evidence and authority to reconsider the outcome.
How long should a one-way video interview be?
Keep a one-way video interview short: three to five prompts with a short answer limit each, so the whole interview takes a candidate about the time of a phone screen. Test the complete route yourself, including instructions, preparation and retakes, before publishing the invitation. If you need substantially more evidence, spread assessment across later stages instead of extending the recording task.
Is a one-way video interview the same as an AI interview?
No: in a one-way video interview nobody responds to the candidate's answers, while an AI interview is a conversation in which an AI interviewer asks the questions, listens and can follow up. Ask for a demonstration using an unexpected answer to see whether the system handles the response or simply advances to the next prompt.
Do you need consent to use AI on video interviews?
In Illinois, the Artificial Intelligence Video Interview Act requires notice, an explanation of how the AI works and the applicant's consent before AI analyzes a recorded interview for an Illinois-based position, and in the UK employers need the candidate's permission to record an interview at all. Present the recording request and any AI explanation explicitly before asking candidates to participate.
Your AI recruiter

Alfa sources, screens and shortlists candidates, so your team only spends time on the people worth meeting.