1. Blog
  2. Recruiting operations

Recruiting operations

In-house recruitment: should you build a team or use an agency?

Alfie Whattam, Co-founder and CEO, Alfa AI ·

A recruiter and a hiring manager at an office desk reviewing a printed hiring plan beside a laptop showing a candidate pipeline board

What is in-house recruitment?

In-house recruitment is when a company hires candidates through its own employees, such as recruiters, talent acquisition partners and hiring managers. For an employer deciding whether to build a team, the question is whether recurring hiring needs justify the team's full cost compared with the agency fees it would replace.

You can bring routine hiring inside and still use external recruiters for selected searches. I'd start with your hiring plan and paid agency invoices: which roles keep coming back, what did filling them cost, and who could run that work internally?

In-house recruitment vs agency vs RPO

Choose the model around the work you need done and the responsibility you want to retain. Recruitment process outsourcing, or RPO, means engaging a provider to run an agreed part of your recruitment process.

AspectIn-house teamRecruitment agencyRPO provider
Who employs the recruiterYour companyThe agencyThe RPO provider
How you paySalary and toolsA fee per hire set in the terms of businessA management fee, a fee per hire or both
Who owns the candidate pipeline afterwardsKeep the pipeline in company systemsConfirm what candidate records you receive; do not assume access to the agency's wider databaseAgree ownership, access and handover in the contract
How well they know your hiring managers and cultureBuild knowledge through ongoing work togetherDepends on the relationship and quality of each briefDepends on how closely the provider works with your team
Best forRecurring hiring with an internal ownerSelected searches and variable demandOutsourcing an agreed hiring programme or process

Use the RPO engagement and contract guide to define scope and handover before comparing proposals. A cheaper proposal can cover less work, leaving your managers to fill the gaps.

What an in-house recruiter does and how they are paid

Give your recruiter responsibility from the hiring-manager intake to the signed offer: writing job adverts, sourcing candidates, screening applications, coordinating interviews and managing offers. Hiring managers still need to define the work, assess candidates and make decisions.

An in-house recruiter is usually paid a salary by the company. Budget for employer costs and recruiting tools alongside that salary.

The US Bureau of Labor Statistics includes recruitment specialists, also called recruiters or talent acquisition specialists, within human resources specialists. It reports a median annual wage of $75,940 for that broader occupation in May 2025. That is a US occupational reference, not a quote for your vacancy or a UK salary benchmark. Use salary data appropriate to the role you intend to hire.

How UK recruitment agency fees work

For a permanent hire, read the agency's terms of business. The employer's fee is set there, often as a share of the hire's first-year salary. Use the agreed basis when checking invoices; do not substitute an assumed market percentage.

Before assigning a role, check:

  • The fee basis and which salary components it includes.
  • When the fee becomes payable.
  • Any refund or rebate if the hire leaves early, including conditions for claiming it.
  • What counts as an introduction, particularly if the candidate is already in your pipeline.

Rebate terms are a matter of contract, not law. Treat the wording you agreed as the starting point.

Section 6 of the Employment Agencies Act 1973 prohibits agencies from charging people for finding or seeking to find them employment, subject to prescribed exceptions. GOV.UK's guidance on agency fees says agencies cannot charge for finding work. It allows charges for certain separate services, such as training or transport, with full written fee details first; those services cannot be a condition of finding work.

Check temporary-to-permanent transfer fees

A temporary worker moving onto your payroll needs a separate check from a permanent-placement invoice.

  1. Check the contractual alternative. Under regulation 10, a transfer-fee term is unenforceable unless the contract lets you choose, by notice, an extended period of hire instead of paying the fee.
  2. Establish the relevant dates. Disregard earlier supplies where a gap of more than 42 days occurred without the worker working for you through that employment business. Then identify the later end date: 14 weeks from the first day worked through it, or 8 weeks from the day after the last day worked through it. The fee is unenforceable if the worker starts working for you after that relevant period ends, under regulation 10's timing rules.
  3. Compare the available routes. Ask for the proposed fee, the extended-hire terms and the supply dates in writing. Check the actual contract and work history before agreeing a direct start date.

Is in-house recruitment cheaper? Use this worksheet

Fill this with your own past agency invoices and salary data. H describes total demand; G identifies the roles whose agency fees you could actually replace.

Roles you expect to fill in the next 12 months (H) = ___
Of those, roles you would otherwise give to an agency (G) = ___
Average first-year salary of those roles (S) = ___
Agency fee, as a fraction of first-year salary (F) = ___

Agency cost for the year = G * S * F

Recruiter salary (R) = ___
Employer costs on that salary: tax, pension, benefits (E) = ___
Recruiting tools and job board spend for the year (T) = ___
Hiring manager hours spent on recruiting, at an hourly cost (M) = ___

In-house cost for the year = R + E + T + M
Agency fee per hire = S * F
Break-even hires = (R + E + T + M) / (S * F)

In this model, every agency hire beyond the break-even number is cheaper in-house, provided the team can handle the work without additional capacity costs. Compare the result with G, not all planned hires. Keep any specialist searches you will still outsource in the budget.

For M, enter the cost of the hours, not the hours alone. Check that S multiplied by F resembles the fees on your invoices; mixed salaries and fee rates can make averages misleading. Include managers' time on both sides when comparing full operating budgets.

The worksheet leaves out gains and costs that are hard to price: employer brand, candidate data the company keeps, knowledge of the hiring managers and the risk that an in-house recruiter leaves. Record those alongside the calculation.

SHRM's 2022 article on recruitment costs cites SHRM benchmarking data putting average cost per hire at nearly $4,700. Cost per hire varies widely by role. Use your own costs to make this decision.

Signals that it is time to build in-house

Look for repeatable work and a clear owner, then test the economics. Expensive invoices alone do not establish that demand will continue.

SignalWhat it suggests
You hire for the same role families every quarterRecurring demand could support an internal recruiter
The same agency invoices recur for similar rolesCompare that repeat spend with the worksheet
Hiring managers spend hours each week briefing several agenciesGive intake and coordination a dedicated owner
Candidates who applied once are lost because nobody keeps the pipelineEstablish company records and responsibility for follow-up
You need to control how the employer brand is presentedBring job messaging and candidate communication closer to the team
A one-off hiring peak or a confidential senior searchAn agency, executive search or project RPO may fit better
A niche role you hire once a yearAn agency may fit better

A 90-day plan for your first in-house recruiter

Agree these deliverables before the recruiter starts. Name a hiring leader who can resolve conflicting priorities and secure managers' participation.

WeeksFocusDone when
1 to 2Intake meetings with every hiring manager and a written hiring planManagers agree role priorities, requirements and decision owners
3 to 4Applicant tracking system set up and agency terms reviewedLive roles and candidate stages are recorded; fee and introduction terms are documented
5 to 6Job advert templates and written screening rules for each role familyManagers approve the templates, requirements and screening criteria
7 to 8A sourcing routine for roles that do not attract enough applicantsSearches, outreach and follow-up have named owners and tracking
9 to 10Structured interviews with a scorecard for every roleInterviewers know what evidence to collect and where to record it
11 to 13A monthly report to leaders on the measures belowLeaders can see hiring progress, costs and decisions needing their attention

Use the screening rule template to make requirements explicit before reviewing applicants. For hard-to-fill roles, build a candidate sourcing process that includes outreach and tracking. Give interviewers an interview scorecard before they meet candidates, so assessments relate to the same job requirements.

Measures to report every month

Keep definitions consistent and show results by role family where useful. Record the underlying counts alongside ratios so leaders can distinguish a pattern from a small set of outcomes.

MeasureHow to calculate itWhat a change tells you
Time to hireElapsed time from a candidate entering the pipeline to accepting an offerA rise prompts a check of time spent at each stage
Cost per hireTotal recruiting costs in a period divided by hires in that periodA change prompts a check of spend, hiring volume and role mix
Share of hires that came through agenciesAgency hires divided by all hires in the periodA fall may indicate more hiring is being delivered internally
Offer acceptanceAccepted offers divided by offers with a final response; track pending offers separatelyA fall prompts a review of candidate expectations and offer feedback
Hiring manager satisfactionRepeat the same post-hire question and rating scale; include response coverageA decline prompts discussion of brief quality, communication and candidate suitability
Retention of new hires at the end of probationHires still employed at probation end divided by hires whose probation end date has passed, using the same cohortA decline prompts a review of assessment, expectations and onboarding

Do not treat a faster process as sufficient evidence of better hiring. Read speed, cost and retention together, and assign an owner to each issue the report exposes.

Where AI changes the in-house decision

AI sourcing, screening and first-round interviews can let a small in-house team cover more roles by reducing manual search, application review and initial interview work. The capacity gain depends on which tasks currently consume the team's time.

Before increasing workload, identify the bottleneck. Automating application screening will not resolve a hiring manager's delayed feedback. More sourced candidates will not help if nobody has time to review them.

Keep a person on the team responsible for reviewing candidates and making every hiring decision. Set job-related screening rules, inspect the evidence behind recommendations and review interview outputs before deciding next steps.

Use this guide to AI recruitment tools to choose a trial around the bottleneck. Compare recruiter time, shortlist suitability and candidate progression on comparable work before changing capacity assumptions in your hiring plan.

How Alfa fits

Alfa AI's assistant, Lisa, can advertise a job, search for matching people who have not applied, screen every applicant against the team's job rules and run first-round AI Interviews to produce a shortlist. The team reviews sourced candidates' email outreach before it starts. A human reviews every AI Interview and decides the next step; Lisa never rejects anyone.

The Forward Deployed Recruiter is an option between hiring an in-house recruiter and paying agency fees. A senior recruiter embeds in your team, learns your roles, hiring bar and culture, and runs hiring on the platform from first search to signed offer. It costs one flat monthly fee, with no contingency fees and no percentage of salary.

The platform's ATS connections let the team search candidates already in its applicant tracking system and send candidates into the right stage. Include the proposed service cost and retained internal work in your comparison before choosing your hiring model.

Frequently asked questions

What is in-house recruitment?
In-house recruitment is when a company hires candidates through its own employees, such as recruiters, talent acquisition partners and hiring managers, rather than paying a recruitment agency or outsourcing provider to find them. Bringing recruitment inside does not require an immediate commitment to handling every vacancy internally. You can define which work belongs to employees and which searches need external support.
What does an in-house recruiter do?
An in-house recruiter is employed by the company they hire for and runs its hiring from the first conversation with the hiring manager to the signed offer, including job adverts, sourcing, screening, interview scheduling and offers. Before hiring one, write down their authority to prioritise vacancies and the decisions managers must still own, so responsibility does not become an ambiguous shared task.
How do in-house recruiters get paid?
In-house recruiters are usually paid a salary by the company they work for, rather than the per-placement fees an agency earns, and the US Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the median annual wage for human resources specialists, the occupation that includes recruiters, at $75,940 in May 2025. When approving the role, ask finance to separate the salary offer from the total employment budget so the recruitment decision uses the full commitment.
How do recruitment agency fees work in the UK?
A UK agency that fills a permanent role usually charges the employer a fee set in its terms of business, often a share of the hire's first-year salary, and by law it cannot charge the candidate for finding them work. Before accepting an introduction, confirm which signed terms apply and who internally can authorise the commitment. Store that agreement with the vacancy record for invoice approval.
Is in-house recruitment cheaper than using an agency?
In-house recruitment is usually cheaper once a company hires steadily enough that a recruiter's full yearly cost is lower than the agency fees it would otherwise pay; below that volume, agencies can cost less because you pay only when someone is hired. That payment assumption applies to contingency arrangements; check the proposed terms. Test the decision against approved vacancies rather than an aspirational hiring plan.
Your AI recruiter

Alfa sources, screens and shortlists candidates, so your team only spends time on the people worth meeting.